Lemon already?

If it is indeed direct injection noise, it may be variable. A quick google search suggests the amount of “ticking” noise can be variable among injectors without an underlying performance issue. Using an engine cover seems to be the most common solution to mute this noise. We don’t have an engine cover on LC.

So the noise will be different for someone with 4 noisy injectors vs one noisy injector.
Why would a noisy injector get less noisy as the engine warms up? There is injector noise but there is also this other thing in this thread that we don’t believe is injector noise. Waiting to hear back from Toyota on the actual issue.
 
Why would a noisy injector get less noisy as the engine warms up? There is injector noise but there is also this other thing in this thread that we don’t believe is injector noise. Waiting to hear back from Toyota on the actual issue.
They operate at a much higher pressure when the engine is cold.

There is a thread on the “other” forum that suggests something like 50psi when warm vs. 2500psi when cold.
 
Last edited:
They operate at a much higher pressure when the engine is cold.

There is a thread on the “other” forum that suggests something like 50psi when warm vs. 2500psi when cold.
engine knock noise
I also don't think this sounds like an injector. But... I have been wrong before. To me is sounds like an exhaust leak but I was told it was a cylinder 1 issue. Still waiting on official word back from Toyota Product Engineering.

Would laugh my butt off if it's an injector.
 
I have this noise and it does go away when warmed up. Seems part of the design, whatever it is since it is NOT random. Only specific engine loads, and only when the temp is coming up.

That said, I haven't given it much thought. My Mercedes had/has a similar lifter noise when cold. MBworld was full of posts deriding MB's downhill quality lol . 16 years and 255k miles later, that motor and transmission continue to set the bar on reliability.

Just because a user says it's a knock, doesn't mean it is one.
 
I have this noise and it does go away when warmed up. Seems part of the design, whatever it is since it is NOT random. Only specific engine loads, and only when the temp is coming up.

That said, I haven't given it much thought. My Mercedes had/has a similar lifter noise when cold. MBworld was full of posts deriding MB's downhill quality lol . 16 years and 255k miles later, that motor and transmission continue to set the bar on reliability.

Just because a user says it's a knock, doesn't mean it is one.
I think most of my comment around knock have been met with “question mark?” After it. Like “engine knock?” I’ve called out many times I thought it was an exhaust leak. The mechanics tore the engine down because of the sound.
 
Someone else in here posted a video of how loud the engine was from outside and I believe that one was presumed to be injectors. I do know on other Toyotas the injectors can be ridiculously loud and it varies in intensity whether it’s in a direct injection or port injection cycle.

Not saying that’s what you’re experiencing just noting that loud seems to be the norm.

The fact they ripped into the engine would seem to indicate at least someone thought there was another culprit.
 
engine knock noise
I also don't think this sounds like an injector. But... I have been wrong before. To me is sounds like an exhaust leak but I was told it was a cylinder 1 issue. Still waiting on official word back from Toyota Product Engineering.

Would laugh my butt off if it's an injector.
It is somewhat similar to the direct injector noise of the Camry engine on this video. Especially after 30 second mark.



Or this video

 
Why would a noisy injector get less noisy as the engine warms up? There is injector noise but there is also this other thing in this thread that we don’t believe is injector noise. Waiting to hear back from Toyota on the actual issue.

Perhaps because the D4S system will transition to port injection at idle once warmed up to prevent low engine load carbon build up, and take advantage of certain engine load conditions where port injection is more efficient than direct injection.
 
Perhaps because the D4S system will transition to port injection at idle once warmed up to prevent low engine load carbon build up, and take advantage of certain engine load conditions where port injection is more efficient than direct injection.
Probably the closest thing I've read on this thread.......
 
Probably the closest thing I've read on this thread.......
Just my guess.

Start with the simplest explanation first.

Why is it noisy on a cold start? Because DI injectors are freakin’ noisy and this engine doesn’t have a cover on it.

Plus the engine will run pig rich to warm up the catalytic converter. The colder it is outside the more racket it’s going to make doing it. Hell it probably runs both DI and port on startup for all we know and sends vacuum to open the wastegate and get heat to the catalytic converter. If it has secondary air injection it will run that too when it’s cold to help push air to the catalytic converter, which makes noise for a few seconds.

Once it’s warm all that will change because the emissions system is “happy”.
 
A little google search got this for me. I know it’s 2021 but sounds like same issue

 
A little google search got this for me. I know it’s 2021 but sounds like same issue

Not the same engine.. is it?
 
I have no reason to doubt the validity, others on hear said they heard the same thing. The question is whether it’s truly an issue, true knock or something else going on. Time will tell, it’ll get sorted regardless. Within 12-18 months the gremlins should be taken care of.
I wish they posted about what kind of sound I should be looking for.
 
Is this an Atkins Cycle 4 cylinder? To me, it sounds like this could definitely have something to do with how the engine has been tuned by Toyota. It might be the kind of thing where Toyota sends out an update on the tune to quiet down this issue.
 
Last edited:
That 3rd video is mine, I'm going with that's normal for direct port injection and from what I've read on this post seems to back that up. I've not been to the dealer for them to look at it.
Mine also makes the same sounds, but here are some examples that others have posted.


 
Back
Top